Government Motors vs Free Market Ford

A picture is worth a thousand words.  Here are several that tell the $82 billion auto bailout story a whole lot better than the Barack Obama Administration has.

We have been told ad nauseum that the auto bailout was unavoidable – irrevocably necessary.  That without it, the entire American auto industry would collapse in a heap.

Well, Ford demurred – they refused to take a government dime. 

So let us compare and contrast $50 Billion-Bailed-Out General Motors and Bailout-Free Ford.  And see what our $42 billion auto bailout loss (and counting) actually got us.

—–

Legend:      

F = Ford (in blue)
GM = General Motors (in orange)

Note:           

“New GM” was borne out of bankruptcy in 2010, which is why their numbers pick up at that time.

Charts From: YCharts.com and Google Finance.

Revenue

 Bailed-Out GM has had consistently higher revenue.  GM and Bailout-Free Ford track fairly evenly, with a between $4 and $4.5 billion (10%-12%) spread.

But that’s revenue.  How did that translate into profits?

Gross Profit Margin

 

Profit Margin

 

Net Income

 

Bailed-Out GM does worse in gross profit, and breaks about even in straight profit margin and net income.  (GM’s late 2011 spike was the result of the federal government making Government Motors purchases.)

How are the shareholders doing?  After all, We the Taxpayers still own 500+ million GM shares – 26% of the company.  And we’re set to lose more than $14 billion – just on the GM stock with which we’re stuck.

Stock Price

 

Bailout-Free Ford has been thoroughly, consistently better. 

—–

So, Bailout-Free Ford has in several key ways done just about as well – or better – than $50 Billion-Bailed-Out General Motors.

So, again, the question is – why did we throw $82 billion down the auto bailout rat hole? 

Print Friendly

Leave a Reply







The politically motivated, wrongful prosecution of Rick Renzi

Rick Renzi Puts Together Top Legal Team to Appeal Hidden Evidence of FBI Agent's Corruption


Judge Unbelievably Refuses to Grant a Retrial for Former Rep. Renzi Despite Finding Rampant Prosecutorial Wrongdoing


Bombshell: New Evidence Reveals Prosecutor Corruption in Trial Against Former Congressman Rick Renzi


Time For a Congressional Investigation: Shattering New Developments of Corruption in Rep. Renzi Trial


Judge Unravels Illegal Activity by Prosecution That Ensured a Conviction of Renzi — But Will he do Anything About it?


Former Congressman Renzi Deserves a New Trial


SCOTUS Turns Down Former Rep. Rick Renzi’s Appeal of Legal Assault






Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner



IC Contributors